Lowering Testing Standards in Third World Countries Essay -- HIV AIDS

Lowering Testing Standards in Third World CountriesABSTRACT Recently, Sidney Wolfe, conductor of Public Citizens Health Research Group (PCHRG), charged the National Institute of Health (NIH) and Center for Disease Control (CDC) with sponsoring fifteen im chaste human immunodeficiency virus studies in sub-Saharan Africa. The trials are being conducted to determine if certain alternate medical procedures or a short course of treatment with AZT, zidovudine or other drugs prevent some mother-child human immunodeficiency virus transmissions. (1) Since the control group receives only placebos rather than AZT, Wolfe claims that the tests give suboptimal treatment that will result in more children contracting HIV and AIDS. (2) Public Citizens Health Research Group and others are calling for an immediate cessation of these important experiments. Public Citizen raises an important moral question. (3) Is it chastely permissible to lower testing standards for the Third World? Unlike PCHRG, I c ontend that the answer to this question is yes, if the trials meet certain conditions. I explain two the world-class Best and Second Best Method (FBM and SBM, respectively) of testing new drugs and then compare the two. Next, I show the FBMs impracticality in developing countries releases researchers from the moral obligation to use it. I then propose a new set of criteria the Second Best Criteria (SBC) that show if a test is moral or not. Finally, I argue that imposing a developed countrys moral standards for clinical trials in the Third World is immorally insensitive to the inevitably and conditions present in the latter area. Section 1In clinical trials there are two different standard protocols for testing new drugs. The First Best Method tests the effects of a known drug (a benchmark), rathe... ...Biotechnology, vol. 11, pp. 135-143.Pederson, Daniel and Eric Larson, Too Poor to Treat Newsweek, 28 July 1997, p. 60.Rath, Richard, Horton Hears the W.H.O. Dissonance, AIDS and Africa Resource page, 3 June 1996, http/www.way.net/dissonance/nyrb_ltr.html, pp. 1-3.UNAIDS HIV/AIDS The Global Epidemic, Press Release, 28 November 1996, http/www.us.unaids.org/highband/document/epidemic/situat96.html, pp. 1-15. HIV/AIDS epidemiology in sub-Saharan Africa, 3 July 1997, http/www.hiv.unaids.org/unaids/press/factafr.htm, pp. 1-3. UNAIDS Announces New clinical Trials for the Prevention of Mother-To-Child Transmission of HIV, Press Release, 9 July 1996, http/www.hiv.unaids.org/unaids/press/mtctpren.html, pp. 1-2No Author Listed AIDS in Africa, The Guide, 9 May 1996, http//www.guidemag.com/newsslant/aids.africa.html. pp.1-2